The Berlin Senate is now automatically checking property listings for potentially excessive rents and writing to landlords. This is sparking debate: is the rent scan a sensible protection for tenants – or will additional regulation ultimately lead to even fewer flats being rented out?
In the 80th episode of the Berlin property talks Achim Amann, Andreas Müller and Vazha deliberately debate this question from different perspectives. This is not just about the rent scan itself, but about a fundamental problem in the Berlin housing market: How can affordable rents be secured without further reducing the supply of rental housing?
Key takeaways from the discussion
1. What does the Berlin rent index do?
The Senate examines published housing offers and alerts landlords if a requested rent potentially violates applicable regulations. In discussions, the letters themselves are initially classified as informational letters.
2. For tenants, the monitoring can be an advantage
Up to now, tenants have frequently had to take the initiative themselves if they suspected a potentially unlawful rent. State inspection can therefore be particularly helpful for people who wish to avoid a conflict with their landlord.
3. Automated checks can overlook the individual case
Things become critical when special features of a property are not sufficiently taken into account. During interviews, high-end renovated flats and new-builds, among other things, are mentioned where automated valuation could lead to incorrect assessments.
4. Regulation does not create additional housing
On one point there is broad agreement: Berlin's fundamental problem is the scarce supply of housing. Tenancy law controls can limit prices, but do not create any new homes.
5. Sell instead of letting?
Drawing from their practical experience, the participants report on owners who are considering a sale in the face of increasing regulation. If previously rented apartments are subsequently bought by owner-occupiers, the supply in the rental market is further reduced.
Affordable rents still do not guarantee access to housing
Very cheap apartments attract a particularly large number of interested parties. Landlords can then choose applicants with high creditworthiness. Price regulation alone therefore does not automatically solve the problem for lower-income households.
7. New-build remains the crucial point
More housing means more choice in the long term and less pressure on rents. During the discussion, lengthy approval procedures, high construction costs and numerous regulatory requirements are cited as obstacles to additional housing construction.
8. Should people rather than housing be supported more?
As an alternative to increasingly stringent regulation, the so-called subsidisation of individuals is being discussed: households that cannot afford a standard market rent are specifically supported, instead of capping prices for all flats equally.
9. The path to home ownership is also up for debate
Another focal point is the low homeownership rate in Berlin. High incidental purchase costs and a lack of equity make it particularly difficult for first-time buyers to purchase their own flat. Therefore, stronger support for homeownership is being discussed during the talks.
What this conversation achieves – and why the video is worthwhile
The rent scan touches on a real problem: many Berliners can barely afford rising rents any more. At the same time, the question arises as to what long-term consequences additional regulation has for landlords, investments and the already scarce supply of rented accommodation.
The discussion makes it clear that tenant protection, new-build housing and residential property should not be viewed in isolation from one another. Short-term interventions can provide relief for tenants. In the long term, however, the housing issue can only be resolved if more housing is created and, at the same time, people with lower incomes are specifically supported.
What does that mean for your property?
Are you renting out an apartment in Berlin and wondering what impact the rent cap, rent index or rent scan will have on your property? Or are you considering whether continued renting is still worthwhile and whether a sale might make more sense?
We will take a concrete look at your situation: sublet, re-let or sell? We take into account the current market situation, the potential selling price and your personal goals.
Get your options checked with no obligation.
German 
English